Sudha Sharma appointed as Member of CBDT    Rupee hits a high of 48.73 against Dollar   Excise Officers caught burning official files in midight in Aligarh after Income Tax raids on Ponty Chadha     SC cancels 122 licences issued by A Raja during his tenure as Telecom Minister    Laxman Das is Officiating Chairman of CBDT    Tariff Value for import of gold is 556 & for silver 1067 & for Brass Scrap 4078 & for poppy seeds 2205-Customs Non-Tariff Notification No. 10   Fused Silica is classifiable under Tariff Item 32074000-Customs Circular No.3  Additional Commisssioner of Income Tax HA Siddiqui sentenced to 4 years imprisonment for accepting bribe of Rs 1 Lakh by CBI Court in Delhi    Exchange Rate for imported goods is Rs 50.20 Per US Dollar & Rs 66 per EURO-Exchange Rate for export goods is Rs 49.40 per US Dollar & Rs 64.40 per EURO    HC upholds levy of service tax on booking of flats-The explanation which was inserted by the Finance Act of   2010 clearly brings within the fold of taxable service a construction  service provided by the builder to a buyer where there is an intended sale  between the parties whether before, during or after construction    Authority for Advance Ruling rules super concentrates shall be classified as products of the chemical industry under heading 3824 90 90 of Customs Tariff      Anti dumping duty imposed on import of Morpholine from China European Union & USA     Anti dumping duty imposed on import of  Geogrid/Geostrips/ Geostraps made of polyester or Glass fiber in all its forms from      Refund of Anti­-Dumping Duty (Paid in Excess of Actual Margin of Dumping) Rules, 2012 notified-Customs Non-Tariff Notification No.5     Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Anti-dumping Duty on Dumped Articles and for Determination of Injury) Amendment Rules, 2012-Customs Non-Tariff Notification No.6     Safeguard duty at the rate of 10% ad  valorem notified on import of Phthalic anhydride, falling under tariff item 2917 35 00-Customs SG Notification No.1     Customs duty on import of Gold, Silver, Cut & Polished Diamonds hiked    Customs duty to be charged at the rate of 2 per cent of Tariff Value on gold and 6 per cent of Tariff Value on silver     Tariff Value for import of gold & silver notified-Customs Non-Tariff Notification No.3     Anti-dumping duty on imports ofSilk fabrics 20-100 gms per metre, falling under heading 5007  originating in, or exported from, China-CustomsTariff Notification No. 2     Anti-dumping duty imposed on imports of Nylon Filament Yarn, falling under Chapter 54 ,originating in, or exported from,  China, Chinese Taipei, Malaysia, Thailand and Korea RP-Customs TariffNotification No.3   Anti-dumping duty imposed on import of Phosphoric Acid of allgrades and all concentrations (excluding Agriculture/Fertilizer Grade) ,falling under tariff item 28092010, originating in, or exported from, Israel and Taiwan-Customs Tariff Notification No.4    Anti-dumping duty on imports of Cellophane Transparent Film , falling under Chapter 39 , originating in, or exported from, China-Customs TariffNotification No.5    Anti-dumping duty onimports of Saccharin, falling under Chapters 29, 30, 33 and 38 ,originating in, or exported from, China-Customs Tariff Notification No.7    Special Bench of ITAT rules the appellant is not entitled to set off carry forward business loss against the long term capital gain arising on sale of land used for the purpose business    ITAT rules Long Term and Short Term gains / losses on sale of equity shares under Portfolio Management Scheme is business income  and not Capital Gains   HC rules the opinion of the AO may have been legally erroneous but this cannot be a ground for initiation of re-assessment proceedings      Anti-dumping duty on ‘Caustic Soda’,  originating in, or exported from, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Japan, USA & France-Customs Tariff Notification No.1    Cost Accountants can issue Certificates for the purpose of refund of 4% CVD-Customs Circular No.1     Customs duty on import from ASEAN nations lowered- Customs Tariff Notification No.127     deeper tariff cut on import from Malaysia notified- Customs Tariff Notification No.128   deeper tariff cuts on import from Korea notified- Customs Tariff Notification No.123  deeper tariff cuts on import from Srilanka & Pakistan under SAFTA notified- Customs Tariff Notification No.125      Schedule of Rates for Service Tax Refund to Exporters notified in supersession of Notification No.17/2009-Service Tax Notification No. 52      Customs duty on import of several products from specified countries lowered-Customs Tariff Notification No.113      Anti-dumping duty on ‘Sodium Hydrosulphite (SHS)’, falling under headings 2831 and 2832 , originating in, or exported from, China PR- Customs Tariff Notification No.111     CBEC specifies documents required for Registration of ServiceTax     Customs duty on import of 532 Products from Singapore lowered-many products exempted from duty-Customs Tariff Notification No. 106     Government allows Rebate of excise duty on export of goods to Nepal under ARE-1 Procedure w.e.f. 1st March 2012-Central Excise Non-Tariff Notification No.24

Services  |  Subscribe  |  Contact Us  |   Feedback   |  E-mail  |  News |  Home
JUDGMENTS
CENTRAL EXCISE
CUSTOMS
SERVICE TAX
INCOME TAX
VAT
FINANCE ACTS
FINANCE BILLS
EOU STPI
SEZ
DGFT
RBI
NTT
RESOURCES


    
Email | Print

Special Bench rules on scope of 158BB(1)

AIT News Network
NEW DELHI. Vide a recent ruling AIT-2006-238-ITAT-SB; Special Bench of ITAT has laid down the law on the following contentious issue referred to it :

“What is the meaning and scope of phraseology, “Such other materials or information as are available with the Assessing Officer and relatable to such evidence” appearing in section 158BB(1) of the Act as substituted by the Finance Act, 2002 with retrospective effect from 1.7.1995.”

 

T H E  R U L I N G:

 In our  humble  opinion   there  should be, in the  first  instance, an  “evidence”   found  as a  result of   search or   requisition of  books of  accounts or  other  documents  that  may  constitute   the  basis of   computation of  undisclosed income.   That  “evidence”  may  not  be   conclusive to   arrive  at  the finding of   undisclosed income  and the Assessing Officer  may   supplement  it  with “materials” or  “information”   that  he  may  gather or   are  otherwise  available with him at  the time of  computation of  undisclosed income of the   block   period.   The  expression “relatable”  appearing in  section 158BB(1)  permits  the  Assessing Officer  to  bring material on record as may  be  required  for  computation of  undisclosed income in  relation to  “evidence”  found  as a  result of  search. All materials or information gathered  by the Assessing Officer or   received  by the Assessing Officer in  the  process of  computation of   undisclosed income  on the  basis of  “evidence”  would  constitute  materials or information  “relatable to such evidence”.  For   example, if  during  the course of the   search  an  evidence is  found to the   effect  that  the  assessee  had income from a  source  not  disclosed  by the   assessee,   all  further  materials or information  gathered  by the  Assessing Officer  in  regard  to  that  source of income  and for  quantification of  the   assessee’s  income  from  that  source  would  constitute  materials or information  relatable  to  such  evidence.   Similarly,  if   for  example,  during  the  course of  search   an  evidence  is  found  as to  inflation of  a  particular  item of  expenditure,  the  materials or  information  subsequently  gathered  by the Assessing Officer in order to  find  out  the other   instances of  inflation  of  expenditure  would  be  materials or information  relatable to  such  evidence.   In other  words, if  during the course of  search  only   a  part  or  portion of  picture is  seen,  the  material or   information  gathered  by the Assessing Officer to   reasonably  reconstruct  the  whole  picture  would  be  materials  or information relatable to  such  evidence.  It,  therefore,  follows  that  while  it is  not  open  to  the Assessing Officer  to  investigate  new  items of  undisclosed income,  he is  entitled  to collect   further  materials or information  so  as to   bring to the  logical    conclusion  evidence  found  as a  result of   search.    The  expression “materials”  or  “information”  are of  wider  import  than  “evidence”  and   as  far  as  the  admissibility of  such  materials and information is  concerned,  there  is  no  distinction to  be   drawn  between   the  assessment  under  the  regular    provisions of the Act  and  block   assessment.  The  burden of  proof,  however,   on the Assessing Officer  may  be   greater in  block   assessment proceedings  than  in  regular   assessment proceedings,  in  view of  the    fact that  while   regular   assessment  is  made  of income,   block     assessment  is  made of   undisclosed income.  While  completing  the   block   assessment  the Assessing Officer  can include   in his  computation of  undisclosed income  only  that  undisclosed  income  that  the   assessee  did  not  disclose in  any income-tax proceedings      the   assessee was  bound  to do  so  or  the  income  that  the   assessee  would  not  have  disclosed in the  normal  course  if  there was  no  search.     While   relying  upon  any   materials or information  as a   supplement  to the   evidence   found  as a   result of  the   search   the Assessing Officer is  not  bound  by   technical  rules of  evidence  and,  therefore,   he  may   take  into  account   facts   and circumstances  that  may  not  be  admissible  under  Indian  Evidence Act  and  he  may    arrive  at  his finding  not  on the  basis of  any direct   evidence of  undisclosed  income  but  on the  basis of  cumulative   effect of all  the   facts and circumstances    relating to  the  proceedings    before  him.

( Click here for full Text of ruling AIT-2006-238-ITAT )    

 

 

  Copyright © 2006 allindiantaxes.com | All rights reserved
website designing India & CMS development: Softlogics & Developments